.png)
Way-Too-Early 2025 Heisman Watch: Top Contenders and Sleepers
The anticipation for the 2025 college football season is already building, and with it comes speculation on who will rise to Heisman Trophy prominence. A mix of highly touted recruits, emerging quarterbacks, and dominant playmakers are poised to shape the race. Below is a detailed breakdown of the top candidates and some sleepers who could make a surprising run for the award.
Top Contenders
1. Arch Manning – QB, Texas
As one of the most hyped quarterback prospects in recent memory, Arch Manning enters his third season at Texas carrying enormous expectations. With the Longhorns fully integrated into the SEC, Manning will need to prove that he can handle the competition and deliver in high-pressure games. His pocket presence, arm strength, and football IQ give him all the tools to be a Heisman frontrunner, but it will come down to execution. If Texas builds a playoff-caliber roster around him and he can put up gaudy numbers, Manning could become a household name in the Heisman conversation.
2. Jeremiah Smith – WR, Ohio State
Jeremiah Smith has the potential to be Ohio State’s next elite receiver, following in the footsteps of Marvin Harrison Jr. and Jaxon Smith-Njigba. With exceptional hands, route-running skills, and breakaway speed, he is expected to be a focal point of the Buckeyes' offense. Given Ohio State’s history of featuring wide receivers in their pass-heavy attack, Smith could amass jaw-dropping statistics. However, for a wide receiver to win the Heisman, he will need consistent dominant performances, game-breaking plays, and a strong quarterback distributing the ball.
3. Cade Klubnik – QB, Clemson
Cade Klubnik has steadily developed into the leader of Clemson’s offense, showing flashes of brilliance while still refining his decision-making. With an elite supporting cast and an offense designed to maximize his strengths, Klubnik is well-positioned for a breakout year. If he can lead Clemson back to a College Football Playoff appearance and rack up both passing and rushing touchdowns, he could emerge as a serious Heisman contender. His ability to execute in big games, particularly in key ACC matchups, will be a determining factor in his campaign.
4. Garrett Nussmeier – QB, LSU
Garrett Nussmeier is stepping into a prime position at LSU, where he will have elite offensive weapons and a high-powered system at his disposal. He has the arm talent to make every throw on the field and thrives under pressure. LSU’s offense has a history of producing Heisman contenders, and if Nussmeier can deliver in big SEC matchups, he could elevate himself into the conversation. His ability to balance efficiency with explosive playmaking will dictate whether he emerges as a true frontrunner or remains a fringe candidate.
5. DJ Lagway – QB, Florida
Florida is eager to return to national relevance, and DJ Lagway could be the key to their resurgence. A true dual-threat quarterback, Lagway has a rare blend of arm strength, athleticism, and elusiveness. His ability to extend plays and create explosive moments will make him one of the most exciting players in college football. If Florida can improve its offensive line and surrounding talent, Lagway could lead a dynamic attack that keeps him in the Heisman conversation throughout the season.
Sleepers to Watch
Jeremiyah Love – RB, Notre Dame
Running backs face an uphill battle in the Heisman race, but Jeremiyah Love has the talent to change that. With his elite vision, acceleration, and ability to break tackles, he is poised to be Notre Dame’s offensive workhorse. If the Irish make a playoff push and Love is a focal point of their offense, he could become one of the rare running backs to seriously contend for the trophy.
LaNorris Sellers – QB, South Carolina
LaNorris Sellers has a skill set that could make him one of the most dangerous quarterbacks in the SEC. He possesses a strong arm, quick release, and the mobility to escape pressure. If South Carolina’s offense takes a leap forward and he produces standout performances in big games, Sellers could emerge as a legitimate dark horse contender.
Carson Beck – QB, Georgia
Georgia’s dominance in the SEC means Carson Beck will always be in the national spotlight. He will have an elite supporting cast, a stellar defense to back him up, and plenty of marquee games to make a statement. If Beck can improve his consistency and elevate Georgia’s passing attack, he could become a serious contender for the Heisman Trophy.
Dylan Raiola – QB, Nebraska
Dylan Raiola’s decision to join Nebraska was a bold move, and if he can turn the program around, his Heisman stock will skyrocket. As a highly regarded recruit with a powerful arm and poise under pressure, Raiola has the tools to lead Nebraska back to national prominence. If he puts up big numbers and secures major wins, his narrative alone could propel him into the race.
Avery Johnson – QB, Kansas State
Avery Johnson is an exciting dual-threat quarterback with immense potential. Kansas State’s offensive scheme could maximize his strengths, allowing him to put up impressive rushing and passing numbers. If he leads the Wildcats to a strong season in the Big 12, Johnson could be a surprise contender in the Heisman race.
Final Thoughts
While quarterbacks remain the dominant force in the Heisman conversation, the 2025 season could bring surprises with breakout performances from skill-position players. The race will be defined by key matchups, signature performances, and which players can elevate their teams in the biggest moments. Whether it’s a household name like Arch Manning or an underdog like LaNorris Sellers, the 2025 Heisman battle is shaping up to be one of the most exciting in recent memory.
